Today, the Joint Committee on Health met for a presentation on Certificate of Need (CON).

First, the committee heard from the West Virginia Healthcare Authority. A volunteer board, through the authority, is responsible for final decisions regarding certificate of need applications, determining reviewable requests, and reviewing any optional violations. The CON process takes anywhere from 60 days to several months. In 2024, the authority processed 35 applications.

The West Virginia Hospital Association presented next. The Association explained that 75 percent of patients are covered by government programs, Medicaid, Medicare, and PEIA. These programs pay below the costs of private insurance. The Association stated that these lower payments restrict the ability to recruit and retain providers. The Association noted that CON is not a barrier to expanding healthcare services. It was stated that West Virginia’s ruralness and sparse populations make it difficult to ensure economically viable services. The Association noted that existing hospitals have expanded services, three hospitals have opened in the last three years, and support programs are available for community needs.

West Virginia is one of 38 CON states. The Association stated that in the last six years, CON has modernized care in the state with more diagnostic care, increasing outpatient care, and exempting birthing centers and hospital services on existing campuses from CON.

Next, a researcher from the Knee Center at West Virginia University provided a presentation on CON studies. He explained that the original goal of CON was to prevent over-providing services such as ambulance services, radiation, hospice, substance abuse treatment services, psychiatric care, and burn care.

He mentioned that the CON process can take months and cost thousands of dollars. In 20 of the CON states, the boards allow 13 incumbents to sit on the board, but WV does not. The boards allow competitors to weigh in on the CON process in most states. CON has a formula including percent utilization. Utilization percentage can prevent CON applications from being approved when hospitals have extra empty beds, competitors can refuse transfers, and differential rules.

According to the researcher, data from 448 tests associate negative results in CON states, including higher spending per service, diminished availability of services, and diminished quality of service. He stated that CON has not affected employment or wages, except for a CEO who received a pay cut. He stated that hospitals do not close with the repeal of CON.

The Pacific Legal Foundation presented that in the last five years South Carolina, Oklahoma, and Montana have all repealed CON. This year several bills have been introduced across the United States for CON repeal. Many states are struggling with an aging population and restrictive healthcare. The Foundation stated that repeal has seen more hospitals open and stay open. Repealing CON has allowed for more clinics, which has allowed nurses to complete clinical hours. Some states have passed legislation exempting rural areas from CON since more services are needed there. The Foundation spoke on the cost-shifting being a myth and that it assumes everyone who needs care is already getting care, which is not true. Although health care is not a free market, it responds to free market principles.

Finally, a presenter from the Cardinal Institute spoke on CON requiring all new and existing healthcare providers to receive permission from a government agency to build, expand, offer new, or update provided services. To the Institute, CON limits the expansion of healthcare. West Virginia has CON moratoriums with few exemptions. CON requires patients to travel farther for care and causes rural areas to struggle with access to care. Patients may travel out of state because it is closer than an instate hospital. Application fees in some states can be $1,500 to $35,000. The presenter noted that without CON hospitals saw higher ratings and that there were lower post-surgery complications.

Today at noon, the West Virginia House of Delegates convened for the first session of the 87th Legislature. The Secretary of State presented the election results from the 2024 elections to the Clerk. The Clerk determined a quorum of 91 of the 99 members. Justice Dan Greer administered the Oath of Office to those members.  An additional delegate arrived before the Speaker’s election and was sworn in as a member, making a quorum of 92.

During the Speaker’s election, Delegates Kelly and McGeehan nominated Roger Hanshaw, R-Clay. Delegates Lewis and Fluharty nominated Delegate Sean Hornbuckle. Roger Hanshaw won and was sworn in as Speaker.

Speaker Hanshaw took a few moments to thank the members, his opponent, and his family. He asked members to reflect on the last 10 years over the next month. The Speaker spoke of the investments in people, hospitals, and higher education and the expansion of infrastructure and healthcare services. He announced that West Virginia has the highest percentage of inward migration in America.

The Speaker said the grand challenges remain across the United States, not just here. Even though there have been investments in healthcare, West Virginia still has some of the poorest health outcomes in the developed world. Even with investments in raises, the state still is not offering competitive salaries compared to other states. Despite increased funding for infrastructure, some people do not have access to much-needed infrastructure. Improvements have been made, but there is still work to do.

Speaker Hanshaw said the future is bright, and he is looking forward to working with Governor Morrissey since his agenda aligns with the Legislature to help people choose West Virginia as a place to live, work, and raise a family.

Clerk Steve Harrison retired after five terms as Clerk of the House. Speaker Hanshaw and Delegate Jeff Campbell nominated former delegate Jeffrey Pack. Pack was elected and sworn in as the Clerk.

Ed Hart was nominated as Sergeant-at-Arms by former Sergeant-at-Arms and Delegate Marshall Clay and Delegate Mike DeVault. Hart was elected and sworn in as Sergeant-at-Arms.

Robert Stewart was nominated as Doorkeeper by Delegates Ellington and Vance. He was elected and sworn in as Doorkeeper.

Three resolutions were adopted by the House today.

House Concurrent Resolution 1 raises a Joint Assembly to open and publish election returns.

House Concurrent Resolution 2 invites the Governor to deliver an address to the Legislature during a Joint Assembly.

House Concurrent Resolution 3 allows the Legislature to adjourn until February 12, 2025, at noon.

The House recessed until the Joint Assembly at 2 p.m. The Senate and the Justices of the Supreme Court of Appeals joined Delegates. The Secretary of State provided the election returns to the Speaker and President. The elected Constitutional Officers are:

• Patrick Morrisey, Governor
• Kris Warner, Secretary of State
• John “JB” McCuskey, Attorney General
• Larry Pack, Treasurer
• Mark Hunt, Auditor
• Kent Leonhardt, Commissioner of Agriculture

Governor Jim Justice provided his farewell address.

The House continued with its business after the Joint Assembly dissolved.

Senate Concurrent 1 is the joint rules of the Senate and House of Delegates.

Senate Concurrent 2 authorizes contingent expenses of the two bodies.

House Resolution 1 is the House Rules; it was referred to the Select Committee on Rules.

House Resolution 2 authorizes the printing and distribution of Acts of the Legislature, Journals of the House of Delegates, the Publication of the Legislative Manual, and the authorization of travel payments and other expenses.

House Resolution 3 authorizes the appointment of employees for the first regular session of the 87th Legislature.

House Resolution 4 declares a vacancy in the 91st delegate district of the West Virginia House of Delegates due to the failure to take the Oath of Office by the Delegate Elect as required by Article VI, Section 16 of the West Virginia Constitution.

House Resolution 4 led to a debate on whether the resolution was constitutional.

Those opposing the resolution argued that while they agreed the delegate elected to the district should not be a part of the body, the proper way to go this would be a motion to expel. The reasoning given was that the delegate-elect did not refuse to take the oath of office, which is what is in Article VI, Section 16. The opposition fears a legal battle about declaring the seat vacant could arise and that it could cause an issue for the other delegate-elects who could not be here today.

Those supporting the resolution argued that the delegate-elect cannot be here to take the oath of office. Supporters stated that while others are not here, they could be if it were not for incidental circumstances. The reasoning provided was that the delegate-elect is unable to be here for legal reasons and therefore should be disqualified from being seated.

The two sides did not agree on the definition of a member. Those opposing stated that one is a member of the House after being elected and certified. Those supporting stated that to be a member of the House one must be elected, certified, and take the oath.

House Resolution 4 was adopted, declaring the 91st district seat vacant.

The House is adjourned until noon on February 12, 2025.

The West Virginia Senate convened a one-day organizational session for the 87th Senate today at Noon.

Senator Donna Boley (R – Pleasants, 03) presided over the beginning of the session as the Senate’s longest continually serving member.

Following the presentation of certified election results by Secretary of State Mac Warner, and the swearing in of newly elected senators by Supreme Court Justice Tim Armstead, members of the Senate nominated and elected Senator Randy Smith (R – Tucker, 14) by acclamation to serve as President of the Senate.

After the election of Smith as President, Lee Cassis was reelected Senate Clerk, David Lavender was reelected Sergeant-at-Arms and Jeffrey Branham was reelected Doorkeeper. All were unanimously approved.

The Senate also adopted several resolutions relating to the Senate Rules and other organizational matters.

The body recessed around 1:30 p.m. to join the House of Delegates for a farewell address by Governor Jim Justice in the House Chamber.

The Senate is currently adjourned until members reconvene Feb. 12, 2025, at Noon for the start of the First Regular Session of the 87th Legislature.

Interim meetings continued today.

This morning, the Legislative Oversight Commission of Education Accountability provided an update on the dual enrollment pilot program. More than 4,600 students were enrolled in the program last year, and 38,000 college credits were earned. The Higher Education Policy Commission spent $3 million but saved West Virginia students $11.2 million.

The Department of Education spoke of improvement in kindergarten through 3rd literacy. The department also shared the harassment, intimidation, and bullying report. Most harassment, intimidation, and bullying take place in 7th through 9th grade. Bullying is usually over race or physical appearance, physical disability, gender identity, or sex.  Most offenders are male. Students who are white are written up at a lower rate than students black or multiracial students.

The Legislative Oversight Commission on Health and Human Resources Accountability met this afternoon. The Commission received an update on the West Virginia Consolidated State Laboratories Facility.

The agencies involved in the consolidated laboratories facility include the Department of Health, the Office of the Chief Medical Examiners, the Department of Labor, the Weights and Measures Division, the State Police, West Virginia University, Marshall University, and the Department of Administration. The design team includes ZMM Architects and Engineers, Cannon Design, MWL, Potesta and Associates, and multiple specialty consultants.

The Site of the Consolidated State Laboratories will be at the West Virginia Regional Technology Park in South Charleston. The entrance of the drive will be expanded. The bid date was November 20, 2024, and K&N Contracting had the lowest bid of $1,650,937. The scope of the work to be done is site prep, grading, and utilities. The work will take place within 180 days from the notice to proceed. The first floor will house the Weights and Measurements Division, part of the Department of Health, part of the Chief Medical Examiner, and the part of the State Police Forensics that is required to be accessible to the public.

The second floor will house the Department of Health and the Chief Medical Examiner and have a meeting space. The third floor will house the Department of Health, Marshall University, and the WV State Police, and it will have a cafeteria space. The fourth floor will house the Department of Health, West Virginia University, and the WV State Police. The roof will have an enclosed penthouse and roof surface.

The exterior of the building is inspired by quilting to pay respect to state tradition. The building layout is influenced by the site layout. When entering the drive, one will approach from the back of the building the loop around to the front.

The completion of the building is projected for mid-November 207 to mid-February 2028.
The Chief Medical Examiner provided updates. While goals haven’t been reached, many improvements have been made. The Bureau of Public Health provided the fatality and mortality report. The committee also provided an update on the Child Welfare Electronic Portal.

Teachers and Principals detailed incidents of child violence and classroom disruption on Monday during an interim meeting of the Joint Committee on Education.

Kanawha County principal Stephanie Haynes told members that she was abused by a child last week for nearly 40 minutes.

“Myself, an assistant principal and another staff member are currently covered in bruises because of this child,” she said.

Haynes and other educators asked lawmakers for legislation to help them remove these students from the classroom so that teachers and students can achieve the safety needed to foster a productive learning environment. They proposed alternative learning spaces and emphasized the need for funding to hire additional staff focused on helping these children.

The educators mentioned that suspension is often not the best option because in some cases it results in sending kids back to a bad home environment. They also described an inability to take away recess as punishment due to the state’s rules on physical activity at schools.

During the 2024 Regular Session, lawmakers considered a bill that would have given elementary teachers greater authority to remove students for disruptive, aggressive or violent behaviors. It outlined steps for how schools should deal with students who needed to be removed from their classrooms. The legislation faced criticism from some that said it would result in children in need of serious mental health support being disproportionately removed from their classrooms. There was also no funding mechanism for the bill.

Lawmakers concluded the meeting by emphasizing that a school discipline bill will again be a high priority during the 2025 Regular Session.